Gaze is an important non-verbal behavior in patient-physician communication. We examine the effect of the physician’s gaze direction in video consultations on their communication and interpersonal skills ratings. 51 subjects watched videos of a physician providing the same teleconsultations while (a) looking directly at the camera and (b) looking at the computer screen. After each video, the participants rated the physician’s skills. The results showed that looking at the camera is perceived as making eye contact and is associated with higher ratings on two communication skill items: (1) using empathy to communicate appreciation of the patient’s feelings, and (2) providing support by expressing concern, understanding, and willingness to help. The effect of eye contact depended on the content of the consultation and on the general attitude of the physician. These results highlight the role of eye contact in video consultations and its dependency on other verbal and non-verbal behaviors.